Create the Ultimate DIY Ice Cream Sundae Bar: A Guide to Sweet Summer Entertaining with Open Nature & Safeway

This is a sponsored post written by me on behalf of Safeway. All opinions are 100% mine.

Imagine the delight of your guests as they approach a vibrant, customizable Ice Cream Sundae Bar – a setup bursting with an array of their favorite toppings, fluffy whipped cream, glistening cherries, and a diverse selection of premium ice cream varieties!

What could possibly be more enjoyable and engaging than a build-your-own ice cream sundae bar? It’s an invitation to creativity and indulgence, where every guest becomes a culinary artist, crafting their perfect dessert masterpiece. Picture a beautifully arranged table laden with various ice cream flavors, enticing bowls filled with an endless assortment of toppings, convenient canisters of whipped cream, and an empty bowl eagerly awaiting a personalized creation. Whether your guests prefer a classic, understated sundae or an extravagant, over-the-top spectacle, the choice is entirely theirs, making this dessert option universally appealing and incredibly fun for all ages.

The Charm of a DIY Sundae Bar for Effortless Entertaining

Summer is synonymous with outdoor gatherings, barbecues, and spending quality time with friends and family. There’s nothing quite like the warmth of the sun, the sizzle of the grill, and the laughter of loved ones. To elevate these occasions, setting up a dessert bar where everyone can unleash their sweet tooth is an absolute must. A DIY Ice Cream Sundae Bar stands out as a brilliantly simple yet incredibly impactful idea for any summer party or casual get-together. The beauty of this concept lies in its minimal effort for the host and maximum enjoyment for the guests.

All you need to do is gather an assortment of your favorite toppings, arrange them attractively, and let the magic unfold. For those who enjoy a touch of homemade goodness, whipping up your own Hot Fudge Sauce can add a special touch. Alternatively, for ultimate convenience, a store-bought bottle of premium chocolate sauce works just as wonderfully. This customizable approach means you can tailor the sundae bar to your preferences, dietary needs, and budget, ensuring you always have everything you need on hand for a spontaneous or planned celebration.

The Star of Your Sundae Bar: Premium Ice Cream Selection

The foundation of any exceptional sundae bar is, of course, the ice cream itself! For my recent gathering, I opted for Open Nature® Scandal-Less Ice Cream, and it truly stole the show. One of the many reasons I adore this brand is its convenient pint-sized containers. This allows me to offer a wider variety of flavors without committing to large tubs, ensuring every guest finds their personal favorite. Open Nature is renowned for delivering high-quality ice cream that doesn’t compromise on taste or texture, making it a perfect choice for indulgent desserts.

Beyond traditional ice cream, Open Nature excels in providing a diverse range of non-dairy frozen dessert options, catering to the entire family’s needs. Whether you’re in the Denver area, where these fantastic products are exclusively available at Safeway stores, or elsewhere, you can easily find Open Nature products at the Albertsons Companies family of stores, including Albertsons, ACME Markets, Jewel-Osco, Vons, Randalls, Shaw’s Supermarket, Star Market, and Tom Thumb. For added convenience, you can also shop for these delightful treats online, ensuring your sundae bar is stocked with ease.

Inclusive Indulgence: Open Nature’s Non-Dairy Options

A significant advantage of choosing Open Nature is their impressive selection of non-dairy frozen desserts. In today’s diverse culinary landscape, many individuals avoid dairy due to allergies, intolerances, or personal dietary preferences. Open Nature ensures that no one misses out on the fun by offering delicious alternatives made with almond milk, cashew milk, oat milk, and even coconut milk. They also offer refreshing sorbet options. This thoughtful approach means you can confidently host a sundae bar, knowing that every single guest, regardless of their dietary restrictions, will have a delectable option tailored just for them. It fosters an inclusive atmosphere, making your gathering enjoyable for everyone.

Essential & Exciting Ice Cream Sundae Toppings

When it comes to ice cream sundae toppings, the realm of possibilities is truly boundless. The key is to select a variety that complements your chosen ice cream flavors and appeals to diverse palates. Aim for a mix of textures and tastes: sweet, tart, crunchy, chewy, and creamy. Here’s an expanded list of beloved toppings, categorized for easy planning, that pair beautifully with almost any ice cream flavor and cater to every preference:

Sauces & Syrups: The Liquid Gold

Classic Chocolate Sauce: A timeless favorite, essential for any sundae bar. Consider both hot fudge and a thinner syrup.
Caramel Sauce: Rich, buttery, and incredibly addictive.
Strawberry Topping: Bright and fruity, often with chunks of real fruit.
Butterscotch Sauce: A nostalgic, sweet, and slightly salty delight.
Maple Syrup: A surprisingly delicious option, especially with vanilla or pecan ice cream.
Sweetened Condensed Milk: A decadent, creamy drizzle.

Crunchy & Textured Delights: Adding that Perfect Bite

Mini Chocolate Chips: Milk, dark, or white chocolate varieties for different flavor profiles.
Chopped Nuts: Peanuts, walnuts, pecans, almonds – offer a selection for variety.
Crushed Cookies: Oreos, graham crackers, or shortbread cookies add wonderful texture.
Sprinkles: Rainbow, chocolate, or themed sprinkles for a pop of color and fun.
Toffee Bits: Sweet and crunchy, perfect for caramel lovers.
Granola: For a slightly healthier and satisfying crunch.
Pretzel Pieces: A fantastic sweet and salty combination.

Fruity Freshness: A Burst of Natural Sweetness

Fresh Fruit: Sliced strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, banana slices, and kiwi add freshness and a touch of tartness.
Maraschino Cherries: The iconic sundae topper, providing a vibrant color and classic taste.
Pineapple Chunks: A tropical twist, especially good with vanilla or coconut ice cream.

Creamy & Soft Indulgences: The Finishing Touches

Whipped Cream: A must-have, whether from a can or freshly made.
Marshmallows: Mini marshmallows add a soft, sweet pillow.
Mini Peanut Butter Cups: Chopped for a rich, sweet, and salty combination.
Gummy Bears or Worms: A fun, chewy option, especially popular with kids.
Shredded Coconut: For a subtle tropical flavor and texture.

When planning your topping selection, think about a balance of colors, flavors, and textures to create a visually appealing and gastronomically exciting experience for your guests.

Setting Up Your Dream Ice Cream Sundae Bar

Creating an inviting and functional ice cream sundae bar is simpler than you might think. With a little planning, you can set up a station that is both visually appealing and easy for guests to navigate. The hardest part, truly, is deciding which delicious toppings to feature!

Organize Your Toppings: Begin by dividing all your chosen toppings into small, individual serving bowls or elegant glass jars. Using clear containers allows guests to easily see the delicious options. Place a small spoon or scoop in each container for easy self-serving. Consider grouping similar toppings together for a more organized presentation.
Prepare the Essentials: Arrange a stack of clean bowls and a pile of spoons at the beginning of your serving line. Don’t forget the napkins! Ice cream can be delightfully messy, especially when kids are involved, so having plenty of napkins on hand is crucial. You might also consider small cups for sauces to prevent too much topping overlap in the main bowl.
Present the Ice Cream: Just before guests are ready to serve themselves, open each container of ice cream. If you’re using larger tubs, you might want to pre-scoop some into smaller, easily accessible containers or chill your ice cream scoops to make serving easier. For Open Nature’s pint-sized containers, simply remove the lids and arrange them artfully. For outdoor events, place ice cream containers in larger bowls filled with ice to keep them perfectly chilled.
Offer Alternatives: For those who prefer a different kind of canvas for their toppings, set out a selection of ice cream cones – sugar cones, waffle cones, or even cake cones. This adds another layer of customization and caters to varied preferences, ensuring everyone finds their ideal way to enjoy their sundae.
Add Personal Touches: Consider labeling your toppings, especially if you have unique or allergen-containing options (like nuts). A small chalkboard or decorative cards can add a charming touch. You can also incorporate themed decorations to match your party’s aesthetic, making the dessert bar an integral part of your event’s decor.

How Much Ice Cream for a Seamless Sundae Bar Experience

One of the most critical aspects of planning any food station is ensuring you have enough for everyone, and an ice cream sundae bar is no exception. Running out of ice cream can be a party planner’s nightmare! A good rule of thumb is to account for approximately two generous scoops per person. This typically equates to about half a pint (or 8 ounces) of ice cream per guest. While some guests may opt for a smaller portion, others will undoubtedly enjoy a larger serving or even come back for seconds, so this average provides a safe and satisfying estimate.

This calculation becomes exceptionally easy with Open Nature Scandal-Less Ice Cream, thanks to its convenient pint-sized containers. Each pint is perfectly portioned, making it simple to manage quantities and minimize waste. Beyond the ease of measurement, Open Nature Scandal-Less ice cream offers a truly guilt-free indulgence. It’s crafted without artificial colors or flavors and boasts a clean, straightforward list of ingredients, allowing you to enjoy every spoonful with confidence.

Depending on the specific flavor you choose, these delightful pints contain between 60-80% fewer calories than traditional ice cream, feature 40-50% less fat, and total only 240-370 calories for the entire pint. This means you and your guests can enjoy the creamy, rich taste of ice cream without the usual heavy feeling. And if, by some miracle, there are any leftovers (which is rare with such delicious options!), you won’t feel a speck of guilt enjoying a few extra bites later. This combination of convenience, quality, and mindful nutrition makes Open Nature Scandal-Less Ice Cream an ideal choice for any sundae bar.

Host with Ease: Tips for a Flawless Sundae Bar Experience

A DIY Sundae Bar is an inherently fun and easy way to entertain, minimizing your work as a host while maximizing guest enjoyment. Everyone delights in the creative process of designing their own dessert, fostering a lively and interactive atmosphere. To ensure your sundae bar runs smoothly, consider these additional tips:

Pre-Chill Bowls and Scoops: If possible, keep your ice cream bowls chilled in the freezer before serving. This helps prevent the ice cream from melting too quickly. Chilling your scoops can also make serving much easier, especially for harder ice cream varieties.
Design a Logical Flow: Arrange your bar in a sequential order: bowls first, then ice cream, followed by sauces, then crunchy toppings, fresh fruit, and finally whipped cream and cherries. This smooth flow prevents bottlenecks and ensures a pleasant experience for everyone.
Keep it Cool: For outdoor events or longer parties, consider using insulated bowls for toppings that need to stay cool, like fresh fruit or certain sauces. Ice buckets for ice cream are a must.
Offer Allergy Information: If you have guests with severe allergies, consider clear labels for toppings, especially those containing nuts, gluten, or dairy. Open Nature’s variety of non-dairy options already helps immensely with this.
Don’t Forget the Ambiance: While the food is the star, a little extra effort in presentation goes a long way. Consider a festive tablecloth, colorful serving utensils, and perhaps some decorative string lights or candles to enhance the party mood.

With Open Nature Scandal-Less ice cream, you can truly embrace the joy of summer entertaining without any worries. Knowing you’re serving a high-quality, delicious, and mindful dessert allows you to relax and enjoy a few extra scoops yourself as you cool off during those warm summer evenings.

I found all the fantastic Open Nature products for my sundae bar at Safeway, but remember, you can also easily locate them at any store within the Albertsons Companies family, including Albertsons, ACME Markets, Jewel-Osco, Vons, Randalls, Shaw’s Supermarket, Star Market, and Tom Thumb. For unparalleled convenience, Safeway also offers excellent Grocery Delivery and DriveUp & Go™ services, making your party preparations effortless. Dive into the world of customizable desserts and create unforgettable memories with your own spectacular DIY ice cream sundae bar!

I created a fun group on Facebook, and I would love for you to join us! It’s a place where you can share YOUR favorite recipes, ask questions, and see what’s new at Dinners, Dishes and Desserts (so that you never miss a new recipe)! If you’d like to check it out, you can request to join HERE.

Be sure to follow me on Instagram and tag #dinnersdishes so I can see all the wonderful DINNERS, DISHES, AND DESSERTS recipes YOU make!

Connect with Dinners, Dishes, and Desserts!

Be sure to follow me on my social media, so you never miss a post!

Facebook | Twitter | Pinterest | Instagram